Skip to main content

Clari5

When A Customer Is Tricked Into Approving A Payment Who Pays?

When A Customer Is Tricked Into Approving A Payment Who Pays?

A CUSTOMER SHARED HER SCREEN WITH A FRAUDSTER. THE BANK WAS ORDERED TO REFUND HER

In 2024, a woman in Delhi received a call from a fraudster and allegedly shared her phone screen. The next morning, two transfers followed: ₹5 lakh and ₹44,488, authenticated with her PINs and OTPs. The bank argued that the payments were authenticated and the loss was hers. On October 28, a Delhi consumer commission disagreed. An OTP proves that the correct code was entered, not that the customer understood or intended the payment. The commission acknowledged that screen-sharing could amount to negligence, but found that the bank had not established that the entire loss was her responsibility. It also found that the bank had not produced sufficient device, IP address, beneficiary and audit records. The bank was ordered to refund ₹4,14,488, with interest and compensation. Authentication alone is not proof of consent. Banks need records to establish what happened and who was responsible.

FROM JANUARY 1, BANKS MUST ESTABLISH WHEN A CUSTOMER IS LIABLE

New directions from the RBI, issued in June, apply to digital payments made on or after January 1, 2027. They extend fraud protection to payments customers make after being deceived or coerced, not just transactions they never initiated. The burden of proving customer liability rests with the bank. Banks must examine complaints and determine liability within 45 days for domestic transactions and 60 days for cross-border transactions. This makes the bank’s investigation and transaction records central to deciding who bears the loss.

REPORT A THIRD PARTY BREACH WITHIN FIVE DAYS AND THE CUSTOMER HAS ZERO LIABILITY

Under the new rules, customers who report a third-party breach within five calendar days have zero liability, and the transaction must be reversed. A third-party breach is one where neither the customer nor the bank is at fault. After five days, liability is determined under the bank’s own policy. Other cases depend on where the fault lies. Banks must also send instant SMS alerts for digital transactions above ₹500. For credit card complaints, they must provide temporary credit within five days. Timely alerts matter: customers cannot report transactions they do not know have occurred.

THE SUPREME COURT WANTS EARLY HOLDS ON SUSPECT ACCOUNTS AND BANKS TO PAY WHEN THEY MISS THEM

At an October 29 hearing on “digital arrest” scams, where fraudsters impersonate police officers and pressure victims into transferring money, the Supreme Court pressed the RBI to finalize its draft KYC rules. The Attorney General told the Court the rules would be notified by November 30 and take effect by December 31. The draft would allow banks to temporarily hold outgoing payments from suspected mule accounts (accounts used to receive and pass on stolen money) for up to 60 days unless police direct otherwise. Account holders would have 20 days to explain the transactions. The Court also said banks should compensate victims, at least for the amount lost, where failures in due diligence enabled the fraud. It noted that bank employees were involved in some scams. The Court is yet to issue further orders. A temporary hold can prevent further loss, but only if the bank identifies the suspect account in time.

CRIMINALS USED LENDER’S OWN CREDENTIALS TO MOVE MONEY. MANY CHECKS WERE BYPASSED.

Not all fraud involves a customer. On October 9, India’s national cyber agency, CERT-In, warned of attacks on lenders, fintechs and wallet operators. Criminals stole the credentials these firms use to move money, then initiated transfers through their own pre-approved systems. Because the requests came from trusted systems, they bypassed many application-level checks. CERT-In noted the likely use of AI-assisted tools and warned that the time between breaking in and stealing funds is shrinking. Separately, a media report on October 29, estimated that smaller non-bank lenders had lost about ₹300 crore to cyberattacks in recent months. With no customer to blame, the loss fell on the lenders themselves. A valid credential establishes access, not whether a transaction is legitimate.

The Account Belongs To One Person But Someone Else Is Using It

The account belongs to one person. Someone else is using it.

 4,086 ACCOUNTS, ONE QUESTION: WHO IS REALLY USING THEM?

Madhya Pradesh cyber police have launched a statewide drive, running until November 28, targeting 4,086 suspected first-layer mule accounts. These are the first accounts to receive stolen money before it is moved further through the network. For the first time, the drive focuses on cases where both the victim and account holder are from the state. In the earlier round, account holders from other states made arrests and prosecution more difficult. Investigators will now examine whether these accounts were originally legitimate or opened for fraud, whether genuine documents were used, who persuaded the holders to hand over account access for a commission, and where the money went next. The previous drive resulted in 26 cases across 12 districts, 46 arrests and ₹13 lakh in frozen funds. The first receiving account is often the bank’s earliest opportunity to stop the money from entering the wider mule network.

83 ACCOUNTS ACROSS 22 BRANCHES, ALLEGEDLY SOLD FOR ₹20,000 TO ₹25000 EACH 

Hyderabad police have busted a gang that allegedly bought bank accounts from local residents and resold them to cyber fraudsters. Each account kit reportedly included a passbook, ATM card, PIN, account details and a SIM card linked to the account, all sent onwards by courier. Police identified 83 such accounts across 22 bank branches. Eleven are already linked to 14 reported cyber fraud transactions involving about ₹10 crore across several states. The worrying part is how ordinary these accounts may have looked individually. The connections between account holders, linked SIMs, devices and subsequent transactions are what can expose the larger network.

A ₹10 LAKH SCAM LED TO 255 COMPLAINTS AND ₹72 CRORE

Mumbai police began with a ₹10 lakh impersonation scam. Following the trail through bank accounts, phones and cryptocurrency transactions led them to a network linked to 255 complaints across the country and approximately ₹72 crore. Six people from three states have been arrested. Police allege that members traded bank accounts and SIM cards in messaging groups and persuaded account holders to install malicious app files that allowed others to operate their accounts. Police have recovered ₹5.5 lakh so far and are still establishing how individual accounts were controlled. The accounts were genuine. The real question is who had control of them, and how quickly the money was moved once it arrived.

EIGHT BANK EMPLOYEES, DIFFERENT BRANCHES, ONE ALLEGED PURPOSE

West Bengal police have arrested a bank deputy manager and seven other employees for allegedly opening mule accounts and routing fraud proceeds in return for commissions. The eight employees were attached to different branches, making the case particularly difficult to spot through branch-level reviews alone. This is not the first such case. In April, Hyderabad police arrested 52 people in a mule account network, 32 of them bank employees. The Supreme Court raised the same concern on October 29. Mule account investigations cannot stop at the account holder or the transaction. They may need to look inside the bank too, connecting account-opening activity, employee involvement and common beneficiaries across branches.

SINGAPORE TOUGHENS SENTENCES FOR YOUNG MULES. BANKS STILL HAVE TO SPOT THE ACCOUNTS.

On November 3, Singapore introduced a bill that would make imprisonment or reformative training the default sentence for offenders aged 21 or younger convicted of scam-related or scam-enabling offences, unless exceptional circumstances apply. It is not yet law. The number of youths investigated for cheating and related offences rose 37%, from 814 in 2024 to 1,114 in 2025. Most were reportedly mules who handed over bank accounts, national digital ID logins or SIM cards. Singapore police receive about 90 scam reports and record about S$2 million in losses every day. Tougher sentences may deter young people from becoming mules, but they do not remove the underlying vulnerability: an account handed over to someone else can become an active part of a fraud network long before its legitimate owner realises what is happening.